Nationalisation is the operation of transferring ownership from the private sector to the public sector. According to the minister of finance, Mr Pravin Gordhan stated on the March 14, 2011 that nationalisation of South Africa’s mines and other economic assets are not government policy. â€śNationalisation of mines means the democratic government’s ownership and control of Mining activities, including exploration, extraction, production, processing, trading and beneficiation of Mineral Resources in article analysis IMG Academy
South Africaâ€ť(ANCYL, 2010). Therefore this would mean that no mines would be publicly owned but they would be owned by the state. It has been sixteen years since apartheid and the white minority of argumentative composition caxton college,
10% of the population owns 80% of the countryâ€™s economic wealth.
The Freedom Charter is a document that expresses the economic, social and article analysis IMG Academy,
political will of South Africans and according to essay writing my best friend taunton school
the document, the mineral wealth of South Africa belongs to the people as a nation. â€śIt is against this background upon which a concrete position on the nationalisation of Mines is formulated in order to guide the ANC in article analysis IMG Academy
the transfer of essay writing my best friend taunton school,
mineral wealth beneath the article analysis IMG Academy,
soil to the ownership and benefit of the people as a wholeâ€ť (ANCYL, 2010). If the state owns the mines it would allow them to manage the economy by controlling the important industries. Xat essay writing University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA).
They could also invest a larger amount of money and make their services more efficient.
Nationalisation of the mines does not mean all sectors are in the hands of the countryâ€™s citizens and that they will benefit from article analysis IMG Academy,
all the sectors. It does not yet say anywhere what the ratio (between state owned and privately owned) of the division will be when nationalisations occurs, if it does. article analysis IMG Academy.
Therefore people shouldnâ€™t think that the state will automatically have over half or a larger percentage. An important factor is whether nationalisation will be with or without compensation. It would almost be impossible to nationalise with compensation as the government currently doesnâ€™t have the figure of about R 2-trillion which is how much it would cost to purchase the article analysis IMG Academy,
mines. But on article analysis IMG Academy,
the other hand, expropriation without compensation would cause a collapse of the Johannesburg Stock Exchange (JSE). This would bring down provident and pension funds at the same time. Writing essays in english American University Preparatory School.
A large number of servants and citizens would be without their retirement investments as well (ANCYL, 2010). Therefore this poses a big problem already. Some people might think why the article analysis IMG Academy,
mines should be nationalised. Below are three reasons.
1. â€śNationalisation to increase the State’s fiscal capacity and better the working conditionsâ€ť (ANCYL, 2010). It states that the money received from writing essays in english american university preparatory school,
taxes is article analysis IMG Academy
not enough to help each and every single South African citizen, which it is not. Education, healthcare, safety and security and housing will not be provided to the masses if the government is not in control of the important sectors. There have been other success stories, such as in Botswana where nationalising the mines provided mineworkers with a safer working environment and higher wages. 2. â€śNationalise to Industrialise and Create more jobsâ€ť (ANCYL, 2010). More jobs will be created and industrial investors will be attracted to add to writing essays in english american university preparatory school
education, expertise and the article analysis IMG Academy,
economy. 3. â€śNationalisation to transform South Africa’s unequal spatial development patternsâ€ť (ANCYL, 2010). This means the areas that will be focused on will be ones which will be sustainable in the future as well as effective. Smaller areas that have never been mined before could be targeted as it will provide more jobs in these areas which rarely see economic activity (ANCYL, 2010).
Malema believes that everybody in South Africa has the right to the wealth that is produced and that the state should own the larger part of the essay writing review chigwell school,
mines. “South Africa is divided as we speak. We’ve got two economies in one country, two nations in one country, and it is nationalisation that will unite us” (Andrew, 2011). Essay writing review Chigwell School.
He also believes many jobs will be created once the mines are nationalised. Writing articles for newspapers Aiglon College.
Patrice Motsepe, a South African businessman, states that he would back Malemaâ€™s decision as long as it is in the best interests of South Africa. The ANCYL believes South Africaâ€™s minerals, water, land and marine resources should be used to maximise growth of South Africaâ€™s economy and not purely for profit (Shivambu, 2010).
If the mines are nationalised, new economic centres will be developed, new industrial development zones will be established, jobs will be created as the mines owned and writing movie titles in essays monkton combe school,
controlled by article analysis IMG Academy
the state will increase local beneficiation and xat essay writing university of california, los angeles (ucla),
industrialisation of the article analysis IMG Academy,
available mineral resources, and local economies will be developed (Shivambu, 2010). General Secretary of Congress of South African Trade Union (COSATU), Zwelinzima Vavi says that â€śNationalisation can bolster our economy and it will always ensure developmentâ€ť (Beukes, 2011). He said that the nationalisation of the mines will make available money to all the people of the country, not only those who are currently working in the private sector (current mine owners) (Beukes, 2011). One of the ANCYLâ€™s argument is that nationalisation was a demand found in the Freedom Charter and article analysis IMG Academy,
that South African citizens should share the essay writing review chigwell school,
mineral wealth of the nation between each and every one (Achary, 2010).
Thus there are valid reasons for the mines to be nationalised but the major concern is writing essays in english american university preparatory school
the cost that the country would incur to make nationalisation happen.
â€śNationalisation is article analysis IMG Academy
an unaffordable, untimely and frankly unnecessary suggestion, which has already undermined market stabilityâ€ť (Time, 2009). article analysis IMG Academy.
It would cost South Africa R1.4 to R2 trillion to article analysis IMG Academy
nationalise the mines which seems silly if you think South Africa has the fifth biggest mining industry in the world. article analysis IMG Academy.
This figure does not include extra running costs as well as the costs that go with running loss-running mines. This shows it is a big part of the economy and would be tough to be nationalised. This figure is article analysis IMG Academy
the same as trebling South Africaâ€™s national debt over a single night, which is unrealistic (Time, 2009). â€śThe debate on the thorny issue heated up with business executives and analysts warning that nationalisation would damage the economyâ€ť (Isa, 2011). Essay writing review Chigwell School.
Many say it is a disaster and writing essays in english american university preparatory school,
has been for every country who has tried to pull it off. Susan Shabangu said â€śconsideration of the step was misguided, as the real issue was to address poverty, unemployment, and inequalityâ€ť (Isa, 2011).
This shows that the writing movie titles in essays monkton combe school,
debates that are ongoing will deter foreign investments. The ANC do realise that itâ€™s close to impossible to article analysis IMG Academy
nationalise the mines and come off on the right foot but are currently looking at models of how it could be implemented effectively (Isa, 2011). The nationalisation of mines has also been seen as a ploy to try and save Black Economic Empowerment (which has been in place in South Africa for a while, but has not achieved what it hoped to) and not focusing on the amount of poor in article analysis IMG Academy
the country as well as the writing movie titles in essays monkton combe school,
amount of unemployed workers (Business Day, 2011). The market value of South African mines (listed) is almost 850 billion rand which is above a third of the essay writing my best friend taunton school,
countryâ€™s total Gross Domestic Product (GDP). Therefore the argumentative composition caxton college,
government should be more concerned over matters such as the education level and the health of the countries people.
â€śZambia nationalised the copper mines, which supplied 90% of its exports, in article analysis IMG Academy
the early 1970s. It ended up hiring back the multinational copper companies to essay writing review chigwell school
manage themâ€ť (News24, 2010). Zambia is the worldâ€™s 11th largest producer of article analysis IMG Academy,
copper. The mines were nationalised in 1969 and at this time were exporting about 700 000 tonnes of copper per annum. By the year 2000, exporting figures had constantly decreased to 225 000 tonnes. The result of the decline was partly because of a lack of investments as well as mismanagement of the mines. â€śZambia has neither the capital nor the skills to run the mines by article analysis IMG Academy
itselfâ€ť (Time, 1969). Other factors were the drop in writing movie titles in essays monkton combe school
the price of copper, a lack of skills among the article analysis IMG Academy,
citizens in Zambia and they were unable to raise capital. They lacked a strong plan with which to writing movie titles in essays monkton combe school
back up their initial aim (Time, 1969).
Restrictions were placed on exports and imports which resulted in exchange rates rising and therefore gains from exports reduced. Essay writing review Chigwell School.
Zambia also failed to save earnings when the xat essay writing university of california, los angeles (ucla),
copper price was high and article analysis IMG Academy,
thus when the price fell, they suffered immensely. Even though the situation is not exactly the same, it does show that to nationalise mines a lot of debate needs to occur as well as research and obviously the country needs the required funds to article analysis IMG Academy
make sure it can be made possible. South Africa does not have these funds at the moment and thus would not be able to nationalise the mines unless they are willing to operate with huge debts which is unfeasible (Osei-Hwedie, 2003).
â€śNationalisation is an unaffordable, untimely and frankly unnecessary suggestion, which has already undermined market stabilityâ€ť (George, 2009). This statement sums up the idea of nationalisation of mines in South Africa. It obviously has its advantages such as giving higher wages and creating more jobs but it is writing movie titles in essays monkton combe school
clearly evident that the positives are outweighed by the negatives. With so many jobs in South Africaâ€™s mining sector at stake, it is irresponsible to talk about essay writing review chigwell school,
placing this key sector of the economy in writing movie titles in essays monkton combe school
the hands of government people. The country does not have nearly enough funds for this project to take place and thus in my view should not take place in even in the near future (Marais, 2010).